FiveThumbsUp

We Bake. You Eat.

Experience Pure Delight

Looking for a delicious baked good or dessert? The Flight sampling of cheesecake. Kringle. Cake Pop. Chocolate Eclair. Cinnamon Rolls. Cookies...and more! Pair it with a cup of fresh-made Copper Rock Coffee or a drink from the bar. Stop-in today or take it to go.
Sign up for our email list

We Bake. You Eat.

Valetine's Cheesecake

Feel the love in every bite this Valentine's Day, with our heart-crafted treats waiting just for you! Surprise your love with this treat! Available in-store or place an order ahead.
Order Ahead

Now Open

Delight in every bite at our new 240 N Broadway spot. Visit FiveThumbsUp Bakery and taste the excitement!

Tues & Wed - 8 am to 2 pm
Thurs & Fri - 8 am to 2 pm; 5 pm to 8 pm
Sat - 8 am to 8 pm

Introducing Our Services

Best Cheesecake Ever

Cheesecake For Any Occasion

Our cheesecakes fit every event, big or small. With rich flavors and a creamy texture, we make the moments in life taste better. Savor each bite and make your celebrations memorable.

Pecan caramel topped pastry with white icing placed in a cardboard box.

Amazing Kringle

Our Amazing Kringle wraps you in warmth and comfort. Each bite features layers of flaky dough, sweet filling, and the love we put into our baking. Perfect for sharing with family and friends or enjoying all to yourself.
Cake Pops

Cake Pops

Our custom cake pops are perfect for any event. We handcraft each pop with care, using quality ingredients. Whether it's a birthday or a wedding, our cake pops add a touch of sweetness.

Our Story

Our bakery began with a simple dream: to bring people together through the joy of fresh-cheesecake and pastries. We started in a small kitchen, a place filled with laughter, hard work, and unforgettable scents.

Today, we still hold onto that dream. Each pastry we bake and every cake we adorn is a piece of our story. Come visit us, and let’s create moments of happiness together.

Contact

Pricing

Smiling female tourist inspecting cupcakes through window of bakery

In the Shop

Varies

per item

More info
Enjoy one of our freshly baked pastries. Ideal for a light snack or a quick bite.

Local Favorites

Daily Specials

Cheesecake Mini
Popular

Cheesecake Mini

$15

per cheesecake

More info
Small indulgence with rich cheesecake flavor. 4.5" of pure delight.

Rich flavor

Perfect size

Creamy texture

Two-tiered white cake topped with flowers, surrounded by various small cupcakes with different toppings.

Event Catering

$250 +

quantity discount

More info
Special treats for your events.

bulk

custom

Slide 1 of 3

FiveThumbsUp is amazing! Their pastries are always fresh and delicious. The staff is incredibly friendly and the atmosphere is so cozy. Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Jessica

FiveThumbsUp's baked goods are heavenly! The flavors are out of this world, and the staff is so welcoming. A must-visit for any bakery lover. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Michael

FiveThumbsUp is a hidden gem! Their baked goods are simply divine, and the staff is always so friendly. It's my go-to spot for any sweet cravings. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Olivia

FiveThumbsUp is amazing! Their pastries are always fresh and delicious. The staff is incredibly friendly and the atmosphere is so cozy. Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Jessica

FiveThumbsUp's baked goods are heavenly! The flavors are out of this world, and the staff is so welcoming. A must-visit for any bakery lover. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Michael

FiveThumbsUp is a hidden gem! Their baked goods are simply divine, and the staff is always so friendly. It's my go-to spot for any sweet cravings. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Olivia

FiveThumbsUp is amazing! Their pastries are always fresh and delicious. The staff is incredibly friendly and the atmosphere is so cozy. Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Jessica

FiveThumbsUp's baked goods are heavenly! The flavors are out of this world, and the staff is so welcoming. A must-visit for any bakery lover. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Michael

FiveThumbsUp is a hidden gem! Their baked goods are simply divine, and the staff is always so friendly. It's my go-to spot for any sweet cravings. Thank you, FiveThumbsUp!

- Olivia

Reach Out Today

We are here to help. Use the form to send us your questions or feedback. We look forward to connecting with you.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Hours

Tue

08:00 AM – 02:00 PM

Wed

08:00 AM – 02:00 PM

Thu

08:00 AM – 02:00 PM

05:00 PM – 08:00 PM

Fri

08:00 AM – 02:00 PM

05:00 PM – 08:00 PM

Sat

08:00 AM – 08:00 PM

Sun
Closed
Mon
Closed